Italy vs Israel 2025: Epic 5-4 WC Qualifier Recap & Analysis

The Italy vs Israel clash in 2025 World Cup qualifying delivered a cinematic spectacle, culminating in a stoppage-time winner by Sandro Tonali. This nine-goal thriller not only showcased attacking brilliance but also exposed defensive vulnerabilities that could define both teams’ qualifying campaigns. For Italy, the victory was crucial to avoid a third consecutive World Cup qualification disaster. Conversely, Israel’s resilience signaled their growing threat in European football. This article breaks down the key moments, tactical insights, and implications of this unforgettable match.

Match Overview: Italy’s Narrow Escape

On September 8, 2025, Italy edged Israel 5-4 in a UEFA World Cup qualifier held in Debrecen, Hungary. The match featured two lead changes, two own goals, and a dramatic equalizer before Tonali’s decisive strike. Italy’s victory propelled them to second place in Group I, tied on nine points with Israel but ahead on goal difference. However, Norway leads the group with a perfect record, making every point critical for the Azzurri.

Key Moments and Turning Points

⚽ Own Goals and Early Shock

Israel seized the initiative in the 16th minute when Manuel Locatelli deflected a cross into his own net. This early setback highlighted Italy’s defensive instability, which persisted throughout the match. Goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma also faced scrutiny for nearly scoring an own goal from a corner, though it was disallowed due to a foul.

⚽ Moise Kean’s Heroics

Italy’s first equalizer came from Moise Kean, who unleashed a powerful low shot just before halftime. His second goal, a clinical half-volley in the 54th minute, canceled out Dor Peretz’s strike for Israel. Kean’s partnership with Mateo Retegui proved vital, as Retegui provided two key assists, showcasing their growing synergy.

⚽ Late Drama and Tonali’s Winner

After Giacomo Raspadori extended Italy’s lead to 4-2, Israel staged a stunning comeback with two goals in two minutes—an Alessandro Bastoni own goal and Peretz’s header. Just as the match seemed destined for a draw, Sandro Tonali’s speculative curler from distance found the net in the 91st minute, sealing a vital win for Italy.

Tactical Analysis: Strengths and Flaws

Italy’s Attack vs. Defensive Fragility

Italy’s offensive prowess was undeniable, with Kean, Politano, and Raspadori combining effectively. However, defensive errors plagued their performance. The two own goals and disorganized marking exposed vulnerabilities that stronger opponents could exploit. Manager Gennaro Gattuso must address these issues to ensure qualification.

Israel’s Resilient Display

Despite the loss, Israel demonstrated offensive potency and mental toughness. Dor Peretz’s brace and Manor Solomon’s creative flair kept Italy under constant pressure. Their ability to fight back from 4-2 down underscores their potential to disrupt Group I’s hierarchy.

Group I Standings and Qualification Path

With this win, Italy climbed to second place in Group I, trailing Norway by three points. The group winner qualifies directly for the 2026 World Cup, while the runner-up faces a playoff. Italy’s upcoming fixtures against Estonia, Israel (home), and Moldova are must-win encounters ahead of their November showdown with Norway.

Table: Group I Standings (After September 8, 2025)

Geopolitical Context and Venue

The match was held in Hungary due to security concerns related to the war in Gaza. Israeli players wore black armbands to honor victims of a recent attack in Jerusalem. Additionally, the Italian Soccer Coaches’ Association had previously called for Israel’s suspension from FIFA, adding a political layer to this fixture.

Conclusion: Italy’s Hope Alive

Italy’s victory over Israel was a rollercoaster of emotions, highlighting both their attacking talent and defensive woes. While Sandro Tonali’s winner keeps their World Cup dreams alive, improvements are urgently needed to avoid playoff uncertainty. For Israel, this match proved their capacity to compete with Europe’s best. As the qualifiers progress, every goal and point will count in this fiercely competitive group. Stay updated on the World Cup qualifiers by following our coverage!

FAQs

1. What was the final score of the Italy vs Israel 2025 match?

Italy won 5-4, with Sandro Tonali scoring the winning goal in stoppage time.

2. Who were the standout players in the game?

Moise Kean scored twice for Italy, while Dor Peretz netted a brace for Israel. Mateo Retegui provided two assists.

3. How does this result affect World Cup qualifying Group I?

Italy moved to second place, tied with Israel on nine points but ahead on goal difference. Norway leads the group with 12 points.

4. Why was the match played in Hungary?

Due to geopolitical tensions and security concerns, Israel hosted the game in Debrecen, Hungary.

5. What are Italy’s next qualifying fixtures?

Italy faces Estonia (away), Israel (home), Moldova (away), and Norway (home) in their remaining matches.

👉For more Sports News → Click here!